# A one-dimensional model of tidal attenuation in the Braithe channel

## 1 Introduction

The tide  entering  the  Braithe  is  attenuated  over  the  eleven  kilometres  between  the  bar  and  Braithe
Bridge, and  the  attenuation  is  large  enough  to  matter  to  anyone  predicting  water  levels  in  the  upper
estuary. This  note  sets  out  the  one-dimensional  model  the  Institute  has  used  since  2018,  states  the
approximation on  which  the  working  formula  rests,  and  compares  the  result  with  the  gauge  record  at
three stations.

Nothing here is new. The intention is to have the derivation, the assumptions and the coefficients in one
place, because the formula has been quoted in Partnership papers without them.

## 2 Governing equations

Take the  channel  as  a  single  reach  of  slowly  varying  cross-section  and  neglect  lateral  inflow.
Conservation of mass gives

$$
\frac{\partial A}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial Q}{\partial x}=0
$$

(1)

where *A* is the cross-sectional area below the free surface and *Q* the discharge through it. Conservation of
momentum, with friction represented in the Manning form, gives

$$
\frac{\partial Q}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left(\frac{Q^{2}}{A}\right)+g A\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial x}+\frac{g n^{2}Q|Q|}{A R^{4/3}}=0
$$

(2)

in which *η* is the surface elevation above mean sea level, *n* is  Manning's coefficient, *R* the hydraulic
radius *R* = *A*/*P* for wetted perimeter *P*, and *g* the acceleration due to gravity. The friction term is the only
nonlinear one that matters over the range of interest.

$$
n
$$

$$
R=A/P
$$

$$
P,
$$

## 3 Attenuation of the leading harmonic

For a channel of nearly uniform depth the leading semidiurnal harmonic decays close to exponentially
with distance upstream, so that

$$
\eta(x,t)=\eta_{0}e^{-\mu x}\cos{(\omega t-k x)}
$$

(3)

with *η₀* the amplitude at the bar, *ω* the angular frequency of the harmonic, *k* the wavenumber and *μ* the
attenuation coefficient. Linearising the friction term by the Lorentz method and collecting terms gives

---

$$
\mu=\frac{\omega}{c}\left(\frac{\chi}{2\left(1+\chi^2\right)}\right)^{1/2},\qquad\chi=\frac{8n^2c\eta_0}{3\pi h^{4/3}}
$$

(4)

where *c* is  the  frictionless  wave  speed  and *h* the  mean  depth.  The  second  expression  is  the  friction
parameter; it is small in the lower reach and approaches unity above  Harrowby  Reach,  which is where
the exponential form begins to fail.

## 4 Application to the Braithe

Taking the mean depth as eleven metres below the bar and four metres at the bridge,  with  Manning's
coefficient at the value fitted in 2018, the formula reproduces the observed amplitude at Vardenne Quay
to within four per cent and at  Harrowby  Reach to within nine.  At  Braithe  Bridge it overestimates  the
amplitude, and  the  discrepancy  grows  through  the  spring  tides,  which  is  the  behaviour  the  friction
parameter predicts.

A two-reach treatment with separate depths would probably remove most of the error at the bridge. It has
not been attempted here because the gauge record above  Harrowby  Reach is too short to fit a second
coefficient with any confidence.

## 5 Coefficients

Manning's coefficient is not constant with depth in a channel of this kind, and the single fitted value used
above is a compromise. Fitting the 2018 record with a depth-dependent form gives

$$
n(h)=n_{\infty}+\frac{b}{h^{1/3}}
$$

(5)

with *n*<sub>∞</sub> the deep-water value and *b* a bed constant. The fit is better in the lower reach and no better at
the bridge, which suggests that the error there is not in the friction term at all.

$$
n_{\infty}
$$

The two constants were fitted to the 2018 record and have not been refitted since. Refitting on the four
years now available would be worth doing;  the  Institute's expectation is that the deep-water value will
move very little and the bed constant appreciably,  because it is carrying the shallow reaches where the
record has improved most.

## 6 Limitations

Three limitations should be stated plainly. The first is the one-dimensional assumption, which fails where
the channel divides above Harrowby Reach. The second is the neglect of the freshwater inflow, which is
small in  summer  and  not  small  after  rain.  The  third  is  the  linearisation  itself,  which  is  a  poor
approximation once  the  friction  parameter  approaches  unity  -  that  is,  in  exactly  the  reach  where  the
model is least accurate.

The error measure quoted in the previous section is

---

$$
\varepsilon=\frac{\left|\eta_{o}-\eta_{m}\right|}{\eta_{o}}
$$

(6)

taken over the spring-neap cycle at each gauge,  with η<sub>o</sub> the observed amplitude and η<sub>m</sub> the modelled
one. It  is  a  crude  measure  and  it  flatters  the  model  at  the  bar,  where  the  amplitude  is  large  and  the
absolute error is not.

$$
\eta_{o}
$$

$$
\eta_{m}
$$

None of this is an argument against using the formula, which is quick, transparent and good enough for
the purposes the Partnership puts it to. It is an argument for quoting it with the reach and the tidal range
attached, which the papers that quote it have not always done.

## References

Sandiman, R. K. (2018). Tidal propagation in the Braithe: a first fit. Tarnbeck Institute internal report TIH/IR/09.
Vale, H. and Croyde, P. (2021). The Harrowby Reach gauge, 2015 to 2020. Journal of Estuarine Hydrology 44,
218-31.
Prosser, A. (2009). Friction coefficients for the Braithe channel. Braithe Harbour Board, unpublished.