TC98 — S88 · New content is added to the source — full evidence ====================================================================== Capability: C36 Knowledge Sync · Query: 'When does the Tromso depot open?' Reference answer: 14 October 2026 Mutation: MS-v0 -> MS-v1 (add B05_tromso_depot_bulletin.md) Corpus: r6-managed-rag-ms-v1 (separate corpus from the SS-v1 stable slice) Slice digests recorded (R6_slice_versions.json): MS-v0: 0c40b34f1fb09799b512bb937465646d14e0a0b2fbf94a6b816ceb4e9d35ec1c MS-v1: 953bb6960d50a9697757a6161813f96cb4b6044e79161df4a585d4cd02907b0a ---------------------------------------------------------------------- STEP 1 — MS-v0 baseline ingest (4 files) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Documents present: 4 - B01_oncall_rota_notes.md - B02_shipping_lead_times.pdf - B03_approved_supplier_list.docx - B04_site_access_notes.txt ---------------------------------------------------------------------- STEP 2 — pre-add query against MS-v0 (baseline, before the mutation) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Generated answer: I do not have enough information to determine when the Tromso depot opens. Top 5 retrieved passages: rank 1 | score=0.8058 | doc=B02_shipping_lead_times.pdf Lead times to the Nordic depots assume a groupage service. rank 2 | score=0.7607 | doc=B02_shipping_lead_times.pdf Central store, Bristol - outbound to depots and customer sites rank 3 | score=0.7504 | doc=B02_shipping_lead_times.pdf Anything handed over after the 15:30 cut-off travels the following working day, and the lead time starts then. rank 4 | score=0.6125 | doc=B04_site_access_notes.txt Codes are held by the service desk and read out on the day. rank 5 | score=0.6068 | doc=B03_approved_supplier_list.docx Review The stores controller reviews this list each quarter with the workshop manager. Any of the 10 retrieved passages mentions Tromso: False This confirms the fact is not inferable/present anywhere in MS-v0 before the mutation. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- STEP 3 — apply the mutation: add B05_tromso_depot_bulletin.md ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Upload response: HTTP 201 (add started 2026-09-10T21:53:58Z, response 21:54:02Z — 4s) Documents present after the add: 5 - B01_oncall_rota_notes.md - B02_shipping_lead_times.pdf - B03_approved_supplier_list.docx - B04_site_access_notes.txt - B05_tromso_depot_bulletin.md ---------------------------------------------------------------------- STEP 4 — post-add queries: 4 independent, identical queries against the same post-add corpus state (no further mutation between them) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- run A (first query, immediately after the add) answering chunk rank: 1/10 generated answer: 'The Tromso depot opens on 14 October 2026 [1].' NOTE: this run's raw JSON was captured and printed live, but was inadvertently overwritten on disk by a later duplicate call before being archived under its own filename. The values above are the actual response as printed and observed at the time. top passages (from the same live printout): rank1 B05 'The Tromso depot opens on 14 October 2026...' (0.7874), rank2 B05 'For the service desk, the Bergen depot...' (0.7445), rank3 B05 'Depot bulletin - a new depot...' (0.7291) run B (duplicate re-run, captured on disk) answering chunk rank: 8/10 generated answer: 'I do not have enough information to determine when the Tromso depot opens.' factual_consistency_score: 0.22460938 full retrieved ranking: 1. score=0.9312 'Depot bulletin - a new depot in the region' 2. score=0.8858 'It is the third depot in the network and the firstabove the Arctic Cir' 3. score=0.7965 'The new depot does not calibrate, does notbreak a calibration seal, an' 4. score=0.7965 'Stop routing northern loan requests through Bergen once the depot open' 5. score=0.7965 'Out of hours the northern sites continue to page the existingduty engi' 6. score=0.7937 'Ringthe new depot directly.' 7. score=0.5511 'For the service desk, the Bergen depot and central stores.' 8. score=0.4808 'The Tromso depot opens on 14 October 2026 and will hold four Tolvan C5' 9. score=0.3512 'One engineer and a shared stores controller, working 07:00 to 15:00 lo' 10. score=0.0989 'What is opening' run C (captured on disk) answering chunk rank: 3/10 generated answer: 'The Tromso depot opens on 14 October 2026 [3].' factual_consistency_score: 0.46289062 full retrieved ranking: 1. score=0.9428 'Depot bulletin - a new depot in the region' 2. score=0.9364 'The new depot does not calibrate, does notbreak a calibration seal, an' 3. score=0.8782 'The Tromso depot opens on 14 October 2026 and will hold four Tolvan C5' 4. score=0.8336 'Out of hours the northern sites continue to page the existingduty engi' 5. score=0.7953 'Ringthe new depot directly.' 6. score=0.7302 'What is opening' 7. score=0.4958 'One engineer and a shared stores controller, working 07:00 to 15:00 lo' 8. score=0.4912 'For the service desk, the Bergen depot and central stores.' 9. score=0.1280 'It is the third depot in the network and the firstabove the Arctic Cir' 10. score=0.1204 'Stop routing northern loan requests through Bergen once the depot open' run D (captured on disk) answering chunk rank: 6/10 generated answer: 'I do not have enough information to determine when the Tromso depot opens.' factual_consistency_score: 0.3125 full retrieved ranking: 1. score=0.9401 'One engineer and a shared stores controller, working 07:00 to 15:00 lo' 2. score=0.9062 'For the service desk, the Bergen depot and central stores.' 3. score=0.7640 'It is the third depot in the network and the firstabove the Arctic Cir' 4. score=0.5911 'What is opening' 5. score=0.3571 'Depot bulletin - a new depot in the region' 6. score=0.1657 'The Tromso depot opens on 14 October 2026 and will hold four Tolvan C5' 7. score=0.1657 'The new depot does not calibrate, does notbreak a calibration seal, an' 8. score=0.1657 'Stop routing northern loan requests through Bergen once the depot open' 9. score=0.0104 'Out of hours the northern sites continue to page the existingduty engi' 10. score=0.0104 'Ringthe new depot directly.' ---------------------------------------------------------------------- FINDING — retrieval always finds the fact; ranking of the specific chunk is unstable ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Across all 4 identical post-add queries (A, B, C, D) against the unchanged 5-document corpus, the added B05 document is always present, and the exact chunk stating '14 October 2026' always appears somewhere in the top 10 search_results (ranks: 1, 8, 3, 6). The fact never became unfindable/omitted at any point after the add — no indexing delay was observed (the very first query after the 201 upload response already surfaced it at rank 1). However, the *rank* of that chunk swings widely run-to-run with no further state change, which in 2 of 4 runs pushed it low enough that generation declined instead of answering (runs B and D), while in the other 2 it was ranked high enough to be cited correctly (runs A and C). This is a generation-layer/reranker-instability finding, not a knowledge- sync failure: TC98's own grading surface is retrieval ('the fact comes back'), and by that criterion it passed in all 4 runs. It is documented here because it directly affects whether an end user asking this question through Vectara's generation layer gets a usable answer on any single try. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- UI verification (console.vectara.com) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Navigated to the mutation corpus (r6-managed-rag-ms-v1) Data tab live in the browser. The console shows '5 documents' and lists B05_tromso_depot_bulletin.md alongside the 4 MS-v0 baseline files — confirmed independently of the API responses above. Screenshot: tc98-vectara-console-mutation-corpus-documents.png